Score: 5

"Killed a good thing."

submission: New Numa

date: September 15, 2006

I enjoyed the first video, as did many. And I don't doubt that a lot of people were asking for a follow-up but I don't think this does justice to the "Numa-Numa" legend.

It's borderline funny. Not the worst thing I've seen, not by far, but I think you had raised the bar a bit with your first video. I think people were expecting something more.

On its own, I think it could have worked.. but I think the custom-made t-shirts, the extra graphics and especially the band plugs were too much to handle and brought the video down. The original Numa-Numa was an underground cult hit. This started out as an idea with potential and turned into a bad commercial for a crappy garage band and a website where you can buy coffee mugs and t-shirts.

I won't call it a "sell-out" because I don't see where you've made any serious money. But the paycheck is all it's lacking.

Score: 10

"Outstanding"

submission: Luis vs. ClockCrew

date: August 28, 2006

Excellent work. You're a very talented flash cartoonist. Good eye for angles, etc and great timing.

All around one of the best flashes I've seen.

Score: 8

"Entertaining"

submission: NewbieScape 6 pt.2

date: August 28, 2006

God rode in on a telle-tubby. That's automatic points right there.